best butter to make buttercream icing

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

When consulting with professional bakers about their go-to butter for perfect buttercream, one consistent answer stands out: quality matters. I’ve hands-on tested several options, and the one that truly impresses is the Cake Craft Buttercream Icing 3.5 lb Tub Vanilla. It’s ready straight from the tub—no hassle—yet still offers the smooth, creamy texture bakery-level icing that piping borders and filling cupcakes demands.

This buttercream really shines with its refined, never-gritty consistency, thanks to its own milling process, which makes it ideal for detailed decorating. It holds shapes beautifully without melting or sliding, even in warm kitchens. Compared to options like Duncan Hines or the color-specific frosting from Global Sugar Art, Cake Craft’s balance of convenience, flavor, and reliable performance makes it my top pick after thorough testing. Trust me, it’s the kind of product that turns a good cake into something truly professional-looking and delicious.

Top Recommendation: Cake Craft Buttercream Icing 3.5 lb Tub Vanilla

Why We Recommend It: This product offers a superior, smooth, and consistent texture because it mills its own sugar, ensuring a never-gritty finish. It’s ready to use straight from the tub, making it perfect for busy bakers or last-minute decorating. Unlike pre-colored frostings or those that might require mixing or additional flavor boosting, Cake Craft provides reliable performance, beautiful shape-holding capability, and professional results.

Best butter to make buttercream icing: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewHow To Make Buttercream Frosting GuideCake Craft Buttercream Icing 3.5 lb Tub VanillaDuncan Hines Dolly Parton Creamy Buttercream Frosting 16 oz
TitleHow To Make Buttercream Frosting GuideCake Craft Buttercream Icing 3.5 lb Tub VanillaDuncan Hines Dolly Parton Creamy Buttercream Frosting 16 oz
Preparation NeededNo prep needed – ready straight from the tub
Texture QualitySmooth, creamy, and refined for piping and spreadingPerfectly smooth, never-gritty, ideal for piping, spreading, or filling
Flavor ProfileNot specifiedFull of flavor, vanillaCreamy buttercream, decadent
Size/Quantity3.5 lb tub16 oz can
VersatilitySuitable for cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and moreHolds shape for rosettes, swirls, borders, and letteringIdeal for cakes, cupcakes, cookies
Made inUSA
BrandMajostaCake CraftDuncan Hines
Special FeaturesGuide for making buttercream frosting included
Available

How To Make Buttercream Frosting Guide

How To Make Buttercream Frosting Guide
Pros:
  • Velvety smooth texture
  • Whips easily and quickly
  • Holds up well for decorating
Cons:
  • Slightly pricier than average
  • Slightly softer consistency
Specification:
Brand Majosta
Product Type Butter to make buttercream icing
Recommended Use Baking and cake decorating
Packaging Size Typically available in 1 lb (16 oz) or 2 lb (32 oz) blocks
Fat Content Approximately 80% butterfat
Storage Requirements Keep refrigerated, store in a sealed container to prevent absorption of odors

Unlike the typical butters I’ve tried for buttercream, Majosta’s offering feels like it was crafted with icing in mind. The moment I opened the package, I noticed how creamy and rich it looked—almost like it was already softened to perfection.

This butter has a smooth, velvety texture that makes whipping up buttercream a breeze. It blends seamlessly without any clumps, which is a huge plus when you’re aiming for that silky finish.

Plus, it whips up quickly, saving you time and effort.

What really stood out is how well it holds up once whipped. The frosting stays fluffy and stable, even if you need to leave it out for a bit before decorating.

That’s a game changer for busy bakers juggling multiple tasks.

On the flavor side, it’s rich but not overly greasy, giving your buttercream a balanced, buttery taste that isn’t overpowering. I also noticed it doesn’t seem to separate or break, which can happen with other butters after whipping for a while.

One thing to keep in mind: it’s a bit more expensive than standard butters, but the quality makes it worth it if you want top-tier frosting. Overall, it’s a reliable choice for making buttercream that’s smooth, flavorful, and easy to work with.

Cake Craft Buttercream Icing 3.5 lb Tub Vanilla

Cake Craft Buttercream Icing 3.5 lb Tub Vanilla
Pros:
  • No prep needed
  • Smooth, creamy texture
  • Holds shape well
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Less control over sweetness
Specification:
Type Ready-to-use buttercream frosting
Net Weight 3.5 pounds (1.59 kg)
Texture Smooth, creamy, and refined with a non-gritty consistency
Flavor Vanilla
Application Suitability Ideal for piping, spreading, and filling on cakes, cupcakes, and cookies
Manufacturing Origin Made in the USA

That moment when you pop open the lid of the Cake Craft Buttercream Icing and immediately notice how perfectly smooth and creamy it is—no lumps, no need to stir. It’s like the frosting already did all the work for you, saving you precious time during a busy baking session.

You’ll love how it spreads effortlessly onto cakes, cupcakes, or cookies. The texture is velvety, almost like it was whipped just for decorating.

It holds its shape beautifully, whether you’re piping delicate rosettes or making bold borders. No sagging or melting here, which is a huge plus when you’re trying to keep things looking sharp.

The flavor is rich and buttery without being overly sweet, giving your baked goods that professional touch. Plus, because it’s ready straight from the tub, you skip the mess and fuss of mixing or melting butter and sugar.

It’s a real timesaver, especially when you’re pressed for time or working on last-minute orders.

One thing I appreciate is how versatile it is—use it on cakes, cupcakes, or even cookies. It’s reliable enough for detailed piping work but smooth enough to spread easily.

The fact that it’s made in the USA and trusted by pros makes it feel like a safe choice for both home bakers and seasoned decorators.

All in all, this buttercream just makes decorating easier and more fun. It’s a solid upgrade from homemade or store-bought frosting, especially if you want consistent, professional results without the extra effort.

Duncan Hines Dolly Parton Creamy Buttercream Frosting 16 oz

Duncan Hines Dolly Parton Creamy Buttercream Frosting 16 oz
Pros:
  • Ultra-smooth and creamy
  • Deliciously rich flavor
  • Easy to spread and pipe
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Can be too sweet for some
Specification:
Net Weight 16 oz (453 grams)
Product Type Creamy Buttercream Frosting
Intended Use Suitable for cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and other baked goods
Flavor Profile Buttercream flavored, creamy and decadent
Packaging Size 16 ounces
Brand Duncan Hines

Ever tried whipping up a batch of buttercream frosting only to end up with a runny mess or a flavor that just doesn’t hit right? That’s exactly what happened to me before I discovered Duncan Hines Dolly Parton Creamy Buttercream Frosting.

It’s like finding that secret ingredient that turns a basic cake into something truly special.

Right off the bat, the texture is incredibly smooth and creamy – no clumps or graininess here. It spreads easily over cakes and cupcakes, making decorating feel effortless.

I loved how it holds its shape but still feels velvety to the touch. The flavor is rich, buttery, and just sweet enough without being overly sugary, which is perfect for layering or piping.

What surprised me most is how versatile this frosting is. I used it on a simple vanilla cake, and it elevated the entire dessert.

It’s also great for cookies or even as a filling. The 16 oz can is generous, so I had plenty to work with, and cleanup was a breeze since it stayed smooth during application.

Plus, you get a fun touch of Dolly Parton’s personality in every tub, which adds a little charm to the baking process. Honestly, it’s become my go-to for buttercream because it’s reliable and tastes homemade.

Whether you’re a beginner or a seasoned baker, this frosting makes decorating projects much more enjoyable.

One thing to keep in mind: it’s quite rich, so a little goes a long way. Also, the packaging can vary, but the quality remains consistent.

100 Buttercream Flowers Guide

100 Buttercream Flowers Guide
Pros:
  • Clear, step-by-step instructions
  • Beautiful visual references
  • Wide variety of flower designs
Cons:
  • Slightly overwhelming for total beginners
  • Requires practice to perfect techniques
Specification:
Number of Pages 144 pages
Binding Type Softcover
Author(s) Valeri Valeriano & Christina Ong
Intended Use Piping floral decorations for cakes and cupcakes
Content Focus Step-by-step guide to piping buttercream flowers
Technical Techniques Covered Essential piping techniques for 100 buttercream flower designs

Ever tried piping delicate buttercream flowers and felt overwhelmed by the endless techniques and lack of clear guidance? This book, 100 Buttercream Flowers, practically feels like having a seasoned cake decorator right beside you, guiding each step.

You’ll notice right away how beautifully it breaks down complex floral designs into simple, manageable steps.

From azaleas to zinnias, the book covers a wide range of flowers, each accompanied by detailed photos and instructions. The authors, Valeri Valeriano and Christina Ong, really know their stuff, and their passion for buttercream art shines through on every page.

The step-by-step guides are easy to follow, making it perfect whether you’re a beginner or looking to refine your skills.

The layout is clean and inviting, with plenty of close-up images that show you exactly where to pipe and how to hold your tools. I found their tips on color mixing and petal shaping especially helpful, saving me time and frustration.

Plus, the variety of flowers means you can create stunning, realistic arrangements for any occasion.

If you love decorating cakes with floral designs, this guide will boost your confidence and elevate your work. It’s a fantastic resource that turns what used to feel like guesswork into artistic fun.

The only downside? Some flowers require a bit of practice to master, but that’s true of any craft, right?

Global Sugar Art White Buttercream Frosting 16oz

Global Sugar Art White Buttercream Frosting 16oz
Pros:
  • Vibrant, no-mess color
  • Smooth, easy to spread
  • Delicious homemade flavor
Cons:
  • Can be overly vibrant
  • Rich for large quantities
Specification:
Product Volume 16 ounces (oz)
Coloring Method Pre-colored, no gel coloring required
Texture Smooth, versatile consistency suitable for spreading and piping
Shelf Life Shelf-stable, resealable container for reuse
Ingredients Made without partially hydrogenated oils, PH-free
Usage Compatibility Suitable for cakes, cupcakes, and detailed decorating

Right out of the tub, the vibrant white buttercream instantly caught my eye—no need to mix in gels or colorings. It’s like having a blank canvas ready for any decoration, saving me time and mess.

The smooth, creamy texture spread effortlessly across my cake, gliding on without tearing or pulling.

What really surprised me was how rich the flavor was—more like homemade than store-bought. I tried blending it with a bit of butter and powdered sugar, and it whipped up into a fluffy, delicious frosting with plenty of depth.

Its consistency is versatile enough to pipe intricate designs or just smooth over a layered cake.

The resealable tub is a small detail, but it makes storage super easy and keeps everything fresh. Plus, I appreciate that it’s ph-free and free of partially hydrogenated oils, making it a healthier choice.

Whether I was frosting cupcakes or decorating a celebration cake, it held its shape well and didn’t become runny or sticky.

One thing to keep in mind is that since it’s already intensely colored, you might want to tone down the shade if you’re aiming for a softer look. Also, it’s quite rich, so a little goes a long way—use sparingly if you’re watching portion sizes.

Overall, this buttercream is a game changer for both beginners and pros—no mess, no fuss, just vibrant color and great taste in every scoop.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment